Breakdown of the PGRE
Posted: Wed Dec 24, 2008 11:45 am
There is no breakdown of what type of questions I got wrong and right on the PGRE. I understand that a basic knowledge of physics is the point of the exam, but different programs should be looking for different things. I know the rest of the application can say how good you are at certain areas of physics, but I don’t see a reason to just send the number of correct and incorrect questions. For example, I don’t know anything about solid state physics, and I am sure that the PGRE accounted for that. On the other hand, I do know a good deal about astrophysics/cosmology. I would think it would be much more impressive to the astrophysics programs that I am applying to that I got an inflationary model question correct instead of a semi-conductor question.
(As a small digression, just to further my point, a faculty member at my university said that the only thing he knew about General Relativity is the principal of equivalence. He was making a point that he didn’t take a course in the field and has no use for GR. I didn’t ask, but I bet there would be some PGRE questions specifically pertaining to astrophysics/cosmology that he would have to look up.)
I realize that this would further bias students who did not have exposure to a particular specialty, but specific knowledge in the field you are applying to should be rewarded. I would love to say in my personal statement that I got all the astrophysics questions correct on the PGRE (which I am assuming is true). What do people think; would seeing a breakdown of the types of questions you got right and wrong make the exam more meaningful?
(As a small digression, just to further my point, a faculty member at my university said that the only thing he knew about General Relativity is the principal of equivalence. He was making a point that he didn’t take a course in the field and has no use for GR. I didn’t ask, but I bet there would be some PGRE questions specifically pertaining to astrophysics/cosmology that he would have to look up.)
I realize that this would further bias students who did not have exposure to a particular specialty, but specific knowledge in the field you are applying to should be rewarded. I would love to say in my personal statement that I got all the astrophysics questions correct on the PGRE (which I am assuming is true). What do people think; would seeing a breakdown of the types of questions you got right and wrong make the exam more meaningful?