Berkeley Physics or Harvard Applied Physics - CM Experiment

[pineapplehead]

Could someone please give me the pros and cons of both schools, I'm very conflicted about where to go. Location is not a huge issue, I'd be down with living in either place. Also I'm not sure what I would like to do specifically in condensed matter, but I'm definitely thinking experimental. Thank you!

[Bozostein]

hmmm... both are excellent schools tough choice

[bfollinprm]

Also I'm not sure what I would like to do specifically in condensed matter, but I'm definitely thinking experimental. Thank you!

Doesn't this answer your question? A physics department will have more varied choices for your research down the line

[grae313]

Could someone please give me the pros and cons of both schools, I'm very conflicted about where to go. Location is not a huge issue, I'd be down with living in either place. Also I'm not sure what I would like to do specifically in condensed matter, but I'm definitely thinking experimental. Thank you!

Have you visited? The cultures and environments at these two schools are very different.

[pineapplehead]

Have you visited? The cultures and environments at these two schools are very different.

Yup I have visited both. Many people have said this to me--and perhaps I'm just incredibly dense--but at least in terms of research I didn't see too much of a difference in environment between the two schools. Both are doing great research and there is a good amount of friendliness and collaboration between groups. Non-research wise I have lived in a Berkeley-type environment for most of my life and really enjoy it, but it would also be nice to live out on the east coast for a bit, which is something I've never done before. I think in terms of lifestyle, I could be happy in either place (I'm pretty adaptable!). Mostly I want to know, where do you think the best research is happening?

Doesn't this answer your question? A physics department will have more varied choices for your research down the line

Really? I think (at least in condensed matter experiment) Harvard applied has a lot of options.

[ol]

Really? I think (at least in condensed matter experiment) Harvard applied has a lot of options.

Most of the faculty in Harvard's applied physics department are also in their physics department. So it doesn't matter.

[grae313]

Many people have said this to me--and perhaps I'm just incredibly dense--but at least in terms of research I didn't see too much of a difference in environment between the two schools.

Yeeeeah... research is not what people mean when they say "environment" But from your answer I can tell you're not the type to care that much and you should just pursue the best research match. Lucky for you, you're choosing between two word-class institutions so neither of them has objectively better research than the other. So this:

Mostly I want to know, where do you think the best research is happening?

is just a silly question. You'll have to pick which place seems to have the most interesting groups to you personally.

However, it sounds to me like you're more keen on Harvard. If you visited and liked the place, just go for it! You can't go wrong here.

[Failnaught]

Have you visited? The cultures and environments at these two schools are very different.

Hm... I didn't apply to these places, but Grae, might you elaborate? Now I'm curious.