How important are derivations and proofs?
 InquilineKea
 Posts: 301
 Joined: Sun Mar 21, 2010 9:07 pm
How important are derivations and proofs?
Derivations are, of course, very important for basic classical mechanics.
But what about things beyond that? What about derivations for the solutions of the hydrogen atom? Or other upperlevel derivations/proofs?
But what about things beyond that? What about derivations for the solutions of the hydrogen atom? Or other upperlevel derivations/proofs?
Re: How important are derivations and proofs?
Important to what?
 HappyQuark
 Posts: 762
 Joined: Thu Apr 16, 2009 2:08 am
Re: How important are derivations and proofs?
Important to a balanced breakfast? CrucialInquilineKea wrote:Derivations are, of course, very important for basic classical mechanics.
But what about things beyond that? What about derivations for the solutions of the hydrogen atom? Or other upperlevel derivations/proofs?
Important to physics? Not really.
Or maybe I've mixed the two up, again.
 InquilineKea
 Posts: 301
 Joined: Sun Mar 21, 2010 9:07 pm
Re: How important are derivations and proofs?
Okay sorry, I meant, important for doing well on the Physics GRE.
i mean, most of the time, you're just plugging in equations you've memorized. Deriving them takes valuable time, and it's better to memorize the core equations just for the test. But sometimes it might be helpful to derive something?
i mean, most of the time, you're just plugging in equations you've memorized. Deriving them takes valuable time, and it's better to memorize the core equations just for the test. But sometimes it might be helpful to derive something?
Re: How important are derivations and proofs?
It's a multiplechoice test on which you have less than two minutes to get a numerical answer to each question, except for a couple of conceptual questions. You better not be working through very many derivations during the test.
Working through derivations in your studying is very good because you see why the formulas come out the way they do, and you're more likely to remember them. E.g., If you've worked through the solutions to the hydrogen atom and harmonic oscillator and infinite square well on your own, you'll easily be able to answer the inevitable questions about their energy levels.
Working through derivations in your studying is very good because you see why the formulas come out the way they do, and you're more likely to remember them. E.g., If you've worked through the solutions to the hydrogen atom and harmonic oscillator and infinite square well on your own, you'll easily be able to answer the inevitable questions about their energy levels.
Re: How important are derivations and proofs?
If your aim is "just" to fair well on the physics GRE, tell the proofs to go to hell. But if your aim is to be a physicist, there is no shortcut. Choose wisely!InquilineKea wrote:Okay sorry, I meant, important for doing well on the Physics GRE.

 Posts: 163
 Joined: Sat Jul 18, 2009 7:24 pm
Re: How important are derivations and proofs?
InquilineKea wrote:Okay sorry, I meant, important for doing well on the Physics GRE.
i mean, most of the time, you're just plugging in equations you've memorized. Deriving them takes valuable time, and it's better to memorize the core equations just for the test. But sometimes it might be helpful to derive something?
If you spend time reading derivations and proofs ... I guess that you don't know how to prepare yourself for that test. You have to be as abstractive as possible if you want to survive!
Re: How important are derivations and proofs?
I hope you're aware that you shouldn't be deriving anything at the actual test in which case I'll interpret your question as "are derivations a useful studying tool for the pGRE". I would say yes, if you have the time. As has already been pointed out, memorization changes to knowing (always superior) when you understand really well the why's and how's of something. In addition, if you know where certain terms in an equation are coming from, you'll be able to modify the equation if a new variation on the old situation comes up. If you're short on time, no way. Work practice problems.